Scientists don’t know much yet about the long-term effects of “vape juice,” the liquid used in e-cigarettes and vaporizers. But researchers analyzing the liquid and the vapor produced when it’s heated say some kinds of e-liquids are reacting to form irritating chemicals called acetals while they’re sitting on shelves.
More than 3 million young people in middle school and high school, in addition to many adults, use e-cigarettes, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Many of them could be inhaling these compounds regularly. And that could be irritating or even damaging to their lungs, Yale and Duke university researchers suggest.
The study published Tuesday looked specifically at eight flavors of Juul e-liquids, which contain a different mixture of solvents than many other brands of e-liquid. These new findings build on similar work the research group published in October 2018 on other brands of e-liquids.
Acetals are formed from alcohol and aldehydes, chemicals used to flavor and perfume foods and other commercial products. While some aldehydes are considered harmful, many are generally recognized as safe to eat and touch, says Hanno Erythropel, the study’s lead author and an associate research scientist at Yale’s chemical and environmental engineering department.
Still, little is known about the effects of aldehydes and acetals when inhaled this way, Erythropel adds, although some research has shown that the acetals can irritate airways more strongly than the aldehydes from which they were formed. And that irritation can prompt an inflammatory response in the respiratory system.
Unlike small amounts of acetals you get through food, Erythropel says, with vaping, “you are breathing this in. We didn’t imagine people would be inhaling flavor compounds at the level they are now. We have very little information.”
At this point, the FDA does not require e-liquid manufacturers to list all the ingredients in their products. So the Yale chemists had to “reverse-engineer” the e-liquids by separating and quantifying their chemical ingredients.
Via this process, the researchers detected the presence of acetals in one of the eight Juul flavors they tested: crème brûlée. This flavor, which uses vanillin for a vanilla-like smell, contains relatively high levels of vanillin acetals, the scientists say. Other flavors might also contain acetals and aldehydes, they say, but they didn’t test in this study for all the possible aldehydes.
Julie Zimmerman, the study’s principal investigator and a professor in the chemical and environmental engineering department at Yale, stresses that much more research needs to be done before drawing conclusions about the safety of e-liquids. Such research needs to take into consideration the possibility that chemical reactions between different chemical constituents of e-liquids may lead to altered products.
Dr. Robert Jackler, a Stanford professor in otorhinolaryngology, which focuses on ear, nose and throat, has studied the rapid rise of e-cigarettes among youth. He says the paper “contributes to the increasing body of evidence documenting toxicological effects of e-cig vapor by specifically testing Juul’s sweet and fruity flavors, which are so popular among teens.” Erythropel is careful to note, however, that any flavored product may contain aldehydes — even a generic “tobacco-flavored” one.
This discovery and others like it suggest there may be long-term health consequences for young people who use e-cigarettes, says Dr. Christina Sadreameli, assistant professor of pediatrics at Johns Hopkins University and pediatric pulmonologist. Sadreameli, who is also a volunteer spokesperson for the American Lung Association, says e-cigarette manufacturers have long positioned vaping as a far safer alternative to cigarettes, with few health effects.
But “this notion [that] ‘it’s just water vapor and nicotine and flavorings’ is very untrue,” she says. “E-cigarette vapor contains a lot of harmful chemicals, heavy metals [and] ultrafine particles.”
The discovery of acetals in e-liquids, she says, “raises yet another reason to worry about what is in the vape aerosol and how that can harm the developing lung.”
Asked about the study’s findings, Lindsay Andrews, a Juul spokesperson, says that the levels of vanillin (which is an aldehyde) the researchers cite in their analysis exceeded “real world” exposures from Juul pods.
Though little is known about the long-term consequences of vaping, some health scares have started to surface. Last week, the Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin announced that eight teenagers had been hospitalized with “seriously damaged lungs” over the month of July.
The symptoms that led to their hospitalization included “shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pain, cough and weight loss,” according to the hospital. Though all the teens improved with treatment, and the exact cause of their symptoms remains unknown, all had reported vaping in the weeks and months prior to being hospitalized.
Zimmerman, Erythropel and their colleagues hope to do more research on the health effects of inhaling acetals. But it will likely be many years before health experts understand the full consequences of acetal inhalation and vaping more broadly, Jackler says.
“Teens acquiring the habit of daily use of e-cigarettes, driven by nicotine addiction, may well suffer adverse health consequences over time,” the physician says. “This means we will not know the full impact of the teen e-cigarette epidemic for decades.”